Rachel Sandwich Recipe

Sink your teeth into a savory, crunchy, creamy delight with this Rachel Sandwich Recipe, my favorite deli classic with a twist. Imagine warm, golden rye bread hugging layers of tender turkey, gooey Swiss cheese, crisp coleslaw, and a tangy homemade Thousand Island dressing that melts into every bite. It’s the ultimate lunch or cozy dinner, perfect for sharing (or not!). If you’re a fan of comforting sandwiches stacked high with flavor, you’re going to fall head over heels for this Rachel Sandwich Recipe.

Ingredients You’ll Need

The beauty of the Rachel Sandwich Recipe is in its simplicity—each ingredient provides a vital flavor, rich texture, or irresistible color to the final creation. Let’s walk through what you’ll need and why you won’t want to skip a thing.

• Mayonnaise: The creamy base for your dressing, providing richness and velvety texture.
• Grated onion: Adds a gentle bite and subtle sweetness to round out the sauce.
• Ketchup: Brings that tangy-sweet kick essential for a good Thousand Island dressing.
• Sweet pickle relish: Little pops of sweetness and acidity that keep every bite interesting.
• Paprika: For a hint of earthy warmth and a pop of color in your sauce.
• Salt: Just a pinch to balance and enhance all the other flavors.
• Rye bread: Earthy, nutty, and robust—this is the foundation that makes this sandwich shine.
• Swiss cheese: Melts beautifully, providing that indulgent pull and gentle nutty flavor.
• Creamy coleslaw: Adds crunch and creaminess all at once, a must-have for perfect texture.
• Sliced turkey: Tender, mild, and protein-packed—feel free to be generous if you’re hungry!
• Unsalted butter: For that crisp, golden exterior that makes every sandwich bite swoon-worthy.

How to Make Rachel Sandwich Recipe

Step 1: Prepare the Thousand Island Dressing

Start by grabbing a small mixing bowl and adding your mayonnaise, grated onion, ketchup, sweet pickle relish, paprika, and a pinch of salt. Stir everything together until fully blended—don’t be shy, let all those flavors mingle! This dressing is what gives the Rachel Sandwich Recipe its irresistible personality, so take a little taste and adjust seasoning if you want it zestier or more tangy.

Step 2: Assemble the Sandwiches

Lay out all 8 slices of rye bread on your work surface. Place a slice of Swiss cheese on each slice—it’s the glue that will meld everything once heated. On half of the bread slices, spread the creamy coleslaw right over the cheese. On the other four slices, pile up generous amounts of sliced turkey. Over the turkey, drizzle or spoon the homemade Thousand Island dressing, dividing it evenly. Top each turkey slice with its coleslaw-covered partner, so the coleslaw meets the turkey in the middle, with cheese hugging both sides.

Step 3: Butter and Grill to Perfection

Butter the top of each assembled sandwich generously. Place the sandwiches, buttered side down, into a preheated skillet or pan over medium-low heat. While the first side is crisping up, butter the other side. Cover the pan loosely with aluminum foil to encourage the cheese to melt. Grill until the bread is golden and crispy, then flip, cover again, and let the second side reach the same beautiful hue. The cheese should be perfectly melted, and the fillings hot. Trust your senses—if the sandwich smells divine and the cheese stretches a little when you peek inside, you’re there!

How to Serve Rachel Sandwich Recipe

Garnishes

I love finishing my Rachel Sandwich Recipe with a sprinkle of extra paprika over the cut halves for an eye-catching touch. Dill pickles or a handful of fresh parsley elevate the visual appeal and add an extra layer of flavor that’s both bright and refreshing.

Side Dishes

A classic pairing with Rachel sandwiches is crunchy potato chips or a tangy dill pickle spear, but don’t be afraid to get creative. Creamy potato salad, simple tomato soup, or a crisp apple slaw all play beautifully with the richness of the sandwich, making every bite pop.

Creative Ways to Present

Cut your Rachel Sandwich Recipe diagonally for a nostalgic diner feel, or stack mini versions on a platter with toothpicks for party-ready sliders. For a more modern touch, serve with a heap of colorful kettle chips or even a small cup of extra Thousand Island dressing for dipping—your guests will swoon!

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

If you find yourself with leftover sandwich halves, wrap them tightly in foil or plastic wrap and store in the refrigerator. They’ll stay delicious for up to 2 days, though keep in mind the coleslaw will soften the bread a bit as it sits.

Freezing

For longer storage, you can freeze assembled—but ungrilled—Rachel sandwiches, tightly wrapped. Place a square of parchment between each, pop in a freezer-safe bag, and freeze for up to one month. Avoid freezing with coleslaw inside if you want to retain the best texture; instead, add fresh slaw after reheating.

Reheating

To revive your Rachel Sandwich Recipe, reheat gently in a covered skillet over low heat to crisp the bread and remelt the cheese. You can also warm in the oven at 350°F (covering loosely with foil to prevent over-browning) until heated through. The microwave works in a pinch, but you’ll lose some crunch.

FAQs

Can I substitute another cheese for Swiss?

Absolutely! While Swiss is traditional for its creamy melt and subtle nuttiness, provolone or mild cheddar make delicious alternatives. Just choose a cheese that melts well and you love the flavor of.

Is there a vegetarian version of the Rachel Sandwich Recipe?

You bet. Swap out the turkey for roasted or grilled vegetables—think thick-cut portobellos, roasted zucchini, or eggplant work wonders. Combine with the same Swiss cheese, coleslaw, and dressing for a superb meat-free version.

How can I make this gluten-free?

Use your favorite gluten-free rye or multigrain bread and double-check that your coleslaw and dressing ingredients are gluten-free. The Rachel Sandwich Recipe is wonderfully adaptable to different dietary needs!

Can I use store-bought Thousand Island dressing?

While nothing beats the freshness of homemade, a good quality store-bought Thousand Island dressing certainly works in a pinch. Just taste and adjust the flavor with a dash of paprika or extra relish if you want it to mimic a homemade vibe.

What’s the difference between a Rachel and a Reuben?

Great question! The main difference: the Rachel Sandwich Recipe uses turkey and coleslaw, while a classic Reuben uses corned beef and sauerkraut. Otherwise, both have Swiss, rye bread, and plenty of dressing. It’s all about your personal preference!

Final Thoughts

I’m so excited for you to try this Rachel Sandwich Recipe—once you take your first bite into that toasty, savory, crunchy masterpiece, I know you’ll be hooked. Whether for a relaxed weekend lunch or a cozy dinner, it’s comfort food at its friendliest. Gather your ingredients, toast up those golden sandwiches, and enjoy every last melty, flavorful bite!

Print